I’ve sat in your seat. I co-founded Koio, a premium sneaker brand, and ran it as CEO for 10 years, through the build, a turnaround and the sale. I now run Commerce Catalyst, where I help founders of consumer brands, usually between $5M and $75M in revenue, with this problem. So I’m one of the options below, and I’ll say where I think each one fits.
| Your situation | Who to start with | What they fix |
|---|---|---|
| You can’t trust last month’s numbers | A bookkeeper or a controller | Books that close accurately and on time |
| The numbers are clean, but there is no forecast, lender plan or board reporting | A fractional CFO | The cash forecast, the lender conversations and the reporting |
| Each order makes money and the shortfall is about timing | A lender | Cash now against sales you expect later |
| The books are clean, you have a forecast and cash is still short | An operator | How the business runs: buying, ad spend, discounts and overhead |
Why growth eats cash
Growth spends cash before it brings any back. You pay the factory for next season’s stock months before it sells, and you pay Meta and Google this week for customers whose orders pay that back over the next few months, so the faster you grow, the more cash sits in that gap.
That gap on its own is manageable when each order makes money, because the cash comes back once the stock sells. The trouble starts when growth covers up a second problem, and in my experience it’s usually one of three: orders that lose money once you count ad spend, discounts and returns; stock sitting in products that stopped selling; or a team and agencies sized for a bigger business. Any one of them means each month of growth pulls cash out instead of putting it back, and because sales are up, it takes a while to notice.
We had the second and the third at Koio. In 2019 the math worked. By 2023 it no longer added up: online marketing had gotten more expensive and consumer spending pulled back. We had also grown from dress sneakers into boots, loafers and slippers, for men and women. Each launch had a good case behind it, but together they spread our marketing dollars across dozens of products, and inventory built up. We understood our unit economics, but we had built a bloated organization and weren’t nearly frugal enough. We kept spending, relying on future growth to justify the burn, and it caught up with us.
I felt it before the data proved it. Then we ran a churn survey and more than 100 customer interviews, and the answer was clear: our core customer was a working professional who wanted comfortable, versatile sneakers for their daily routine. So we went back to sneakers. We also cut marketing costs, closed unprofitable stores and renegotiated every vendor contract. In 18 months we went from roughly negative $3M EBITDA to profitability. Going back to sneakers was the most important piece, because everything else got easier once we knew what we were. It’s also where my rule to review your P&L every single week comes from.
When a bookkeeper, controller or fractional CFO is the right hire
If the month closes late, if inventory on the balance sheet doesn’t match the warehouse, or if nobody can tell you what you spent on marketing last month, fix that first, because every other decision depends on numbers you trust. For a young brand that’s a bookkeeper who knows e-commerce. Once the business is big enough to have lenders or investors looking at the numbers, a controller who closes the month accurately and on time is the hire to make.
A fractional CFO sits a level above that. When you talk to one, ask them to walk you through what they’d own: the cash forecast, the lender conversations, the board reporting. Then ask what they’d do about the operating side: what to stop buying, which channel to cut, which contracts to renegotiate. You want to know whether they’ll take that on before you start.
When a lender is the right answer
Here’s how I’d think about borrowing. Inventory financing, revenue-based financing and a credit line all put cash in the business now against sales you expect later. That can be the right tool when each order makes money and the shortfall is about timing. At Koio, through the turnaround, the only outside money besides our shareholders was inventory financing, and the stock it paid for covered it at all times.
When orders lose money, though, a loan funds the losses and then comes due on top of them. Profitability creates options. Dependence on outside capital narrows them. So before you sign anything, put the repayments into your 13-week cash forecast and check that you still have cash in the lowest week.
When you need an operator
If your books are clean, you have a forecast and cash is still always short, my read is that you’re dealing with something like what we had at Koio. Finding and fixing that is the work I do now.
The first places I look are the gap between what you pay to win a customer and what that customer is worth after returns and discounts, the stock tied up in products that stopped selling, how often you’re discounting to make the month, and the agencies and software you wouldn’t sign up for again today.
Fixing it means cutting the ad spend that doesn’t pay back, clearing the slow stock, ending those discounts and dropping what you no longer need. Then the changes have to be carried out with the team, week after week. If you want help with that part, I can run the business alongside you.
How to tell which one you need
Whoever ends up helping you, start with a 13-week cash forecast. It shows you the week when cash is lowest and how low it gets. Then I’d ask three questions:
- Can you trust last month’s numbers? If you can’t, the bookkeeper or controller comes first.
- Does an order make money after ad spend, discounts, returns and shipping? The forecast won’t tell you this, so work it out by channel. If orders make money and the low point is a timing gap, borrowing can carry you through it. If they don’t, the fix is in the business.
- How much cash is sitting in stock that sells slowly? If it’s a big share of what you’re short, the answer is in buying and inventory, and that’s operating work.
There’s a step-by-step guide to building a 13-week cash flow forecast on this site if you want to do the first part yourself. If you’d rather go through it with someone, that’s what the Cash Review is for: four weeks at a fixed price of $15,000, and you come out with the 13-week cash plan and the three changes that free up the most cash.
Questions founders ask
Why does my brand have less money in the bank when sales are up?
Growth spends cash on inventory and marketing before the sales from them arrive. If orders also lose money after ad spend, discounts and returns, selling more pulls even more cash out. The 13-week forecast shows when cash runs lowest, and a margin check on each order by channel shows whether the second problem is there too.
Who can build a 13-week cash forecast for my brand?
A controller or a fractional CFO can build one, and the guide linked above shows how to build it yourself. I build it as part of the Cash Review, together with a review of your ad accounts, inventory, margins, bills and debt, so that the forecast comes with the changes that free up cash.
Should I take inventory financing or a revenue-based loan?
It can be the right tool when each order makes money and the shortfall is timing. When orders lose money, the loan funds the losses. Either way, put the repayments into your cash forecast and check the lowest week before you sign.
Do I need a fractional CFO or a fractional COO?
If the forecast, the reporting and the lender conversations are what’s missing, start with the finance side. If you already have a good forecast and cash is still short, look at how the business runs: buying, marketing spend, vendor terms and overhead. That’s operating work, and it’s what a fractional COO or an operator is there to change.
What does the Cash Review cost, and how long does it take?
Four weeks at a fixed price of $15,000. You come out with a 13-week cash plan, the week when cash is lowest, and the three changes that free up the most cash, each with a dollar amount and an owner.